Dec 17, 2012 in jackson s story, though, the dwarves are utterly fearless and possessed of sufficient battle prowess that bilbos cleverness, or lack thereof, is largely beside the point. Tolkiens first middleearth fantasy novel, bilbo baggins martin freeman sets out with the wizard gandalf. The hobbit, or there and back again is a childrens fantasy novel by english author j. Professor shippey was the literary consultant to jackson and the actors as. Peter jackson has revealed he began filming his blockbuster hobbit trilogy without proper preparation, in many cases shooting scenes without storyboards and completed scripts in a. But jackson s version, coming off of the steam and success of the more mature lord of the rings lotr series, presents a darker, adult adaptation. Peter jackson explains why you should see the hobbit in 48. May 04, 2014 director sir peter jackson talks with tolkienfan cirdan about his early doubts regarding the hobbit adaption, changes to the book by j.
This third installment of the hobbit trilogy is allegedly the shortest of all of peter jackson s tolkien films, but my theater must have been orbiting a black hole because i could swear it. Dec, 2011 whats the hardest part of casting the hobbit. Director peter jackson in his film adaptation of the hobbit abandons the. This is jackson s take on it, and i think this is how it should be looked at. Tolkien controversial childrens book yes, the hobbit is riddled with controversies. The vision of freedom that tolkien got, and the west forgot. The ultimate celebration of the first hobbit movie reveals the full creative. Tolkiens first middleearth adventure was the hobbit. R tolkien that takes place in the fictional world of middle earth, which is the setting of most of the authors works. Originally, when they find the swords,gandalf says if we can read the runes on them, we shall know more about them. The hobbit director peter jackson has some bad news and some good news for fans. Jackson will spend his christmas break cutting the first film into shape. I spied the first part of sir peter jackson s tripartite adaptation of j. The book separates commentary from tolkiens text, allowing the reader to read the original drafts as selfcontained stories.
Tolkien, with large portions of the trilogy inspired by the appendices to the return of the king, which expand on the story told in the hobbit, as well as new material and characters written especially for the films. I liked the the trolls in the hobbit better than lotr. Tolkiens the hobbit, the argument i dont see why it needs to be three films when its such a small book. Ever since peter jackson revealed his plan to expand his adaptation of j. Why the hobbit wasnt better, according to peter jackson.
The hobbit peter jackson reason for changes from the. The desolation of smaug, peter jackson s second movie of three based on the book by j. There can be no follow up trilogy set after the lord of the rings. The director has made blinkandyoumightmissit guest. Peter jackson was going to get martin freeman to middleearth, no matter what it took the 41year old english actor, best known right now for his work as watson on bbcs sherlock, plays the. Peter jackson s next project, mortal engines, is based on a fantasy book series with a number of sequels and prequels. The final part of jackson s hobbit trilogy, the battle of the five armies, arrives in cinemas this weekend, like the final season of a steadily worsening.
In fact, tolkien once did draft one chapter of a story that was to be set in gondor some time after the death of king elessar aragorn, b. The book is packed with more than 1,000 images of concept artwork. Dec 10, 2012 there is a sense of sledgehammers being used to crack nuts in the first part of peter jacksons hobbit trilogy. Jun 25, 20 an extended version of jacksons the hobbit. Peter jackson and the making of middleearth english. Tolkiens the hobbit, as a book, never had enough material within it for it to be spun out into a trilogy and jackson. One may or may not agree with this way of showing the hobbit. They eviscerated the book by making it an action movie for young people aged 15 to 25, christopher says regretfully. Dec, 2012 peter jackson is taking what he hopes is a huge leap into the future this weekend, releasing the hobbit. How faithful is peter jacksons hobbit to tolkiens book. What were peter jacksons cameos in the hobbit and lord of. The hobbit the battle of the five armies peter jacksons.
Director and allaround tolkien movie guru peter jackson joins with his. How faithful are the hobbit films to tolkiens books. Interesting answers so far, and i agree with much of whats said. It represents the culmination of his 16year, sixfilm j. Peter jackson is evidently one of those people who would refer to jeff bridges jeffrey lebowski as duderino as he clearly isnt into the whole brevity thing. The hobbit movies were way worse than the lord of the rings movies but they did have some good stuff in them. Peter jackson will not be making the hobbit slashdot. Nov 19, 2015 that was a jarring experience for many who grew up loving director peter jacksons initial movie trilogy adaptation of j. Peter jackson explains all of the hobbit movie problems film.
Tolkiens short 1937 novel, a prequel to the lord of the rings, has been. Aug 15, 2015 the hobbit book to film analysis chapter one an unexpected party bilbo from the book is a fundamentally different character than martin freemans character depicted in the film, albeit the role and essence are the same. Also, to play through the directors commentary, the scriptwriters commentary, the cast. The desolation of smaug original motion picture soundtrack special edition.
Peter jackson, fran walsh, philippa boyens, and guillermo del toro starring. I didnt know what the hell i was doing when i made. The complete list of film changes for the hobbit and the lord of the rings. So i think peter expanded azogs role for several reasons. Well, let me explain why although originally intended to be a onefilm adaptation followed by an. Something i heard on the directors commentary i was listening to the director commentary for the hobbit. Breaking the hobbit into three films and adding tons of stuff that didnt happen is a problem for me. In the book, elrond does so by reading the runes on the sword. An anonymous reader writes due to legal wranglings with new line cinema over accounting issues for lord of the rings, peter jackson and fran walsh will not be involved in the making of either the hobbit or the planned lord of the rings prequel. Jul 14, 2017 peter jacksons much anticipated the hobbit hits theaters today. Peter jacksons comments provoke a gathering storm in a. Like a lot of people, i loved peter jackson s original lord of the rings trilogy although we can all admit return of the king didnt quite know when to leave the party. Recently, however, ignatius press has published a book on the topic by jonathan witt and jay w.
In praise of peter jacksons hobbit tolkien books, jrr. Jan 15, 2014 peter jackson loves a good cameo and one resourceful fan has made gifs of all of his cameos in the lord of the rings and hobbit films. On the down side, there wont be any presentation at comiccon this year. Tolkiens the hobbit curiously resubtitled an unexpected journey as opposed to the original there and back again. The gathering storm on the making of the hobbit trilogy has gone viral online, unleashing much debate among fans who love or hate the movies. Cook comments friends, elves and hobbits, lend me your ears. An unexpected journey in 48 frames per second a highframerate format that essentially. Bbc radio 4 the film programme, peter jackson on the hobbit. Cameo appearances in peter jacksons the lord of the rings.
Jan 28, 20 invited to meet peter jackson, the tolkien family preferred not to. For with the desolation of smaug soon out on dvd i come to praise peter jacksons interpretation of the hobbit, not to bury it. Apr 19, 2015 with the next film in the hobbit trilogy on its way december subtitled the desolation of smauglets take a guided trip through middleearth with peter jackson to help steer us through. Peter jackson has, at long last, made an official announcement about who will appear in the hobbit. Comparing to the book, leaves, well it is not the same lets put it this way. The appendices parts 7 and 8 visit dwarf boot camp, live alongside the filmmakers, and talk to the geniuses at weta digital. Peter jacksons hobbit trilogy becomes most expensive film. Even the most ardent defenders of peter jackson s threefilm adaptation of j. When the scene of gollum came up the subject arose if peter jackson would ever change the scene of ian holm finding the ring in fotr and put in martin freeman instead. It seems every critic on the internet is determined to point out the differences between peter jackson s first hobbit movie and j. Peter jacksons hobbit is more faithful to the books than.
If peter jackson decides to make a third trilogy, to follow. Peter jackson wants the hobbit to be a trilogy digital trends. The hobbit is a film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by peter jackson. Dec 11, 20 peter jackson explains why the hobbit has to be three movies due to the ongoing covid19 pandemic, our coverage will be reduced. Peter jackson defends making the hobbit a trilogy e. Ian mckellen, martin freeman, richard armitage, lee pace, luke evans, evangeline lilly. The fellowship of the ring gino acevedo senior prosthetics supervisor and visual creature special effects art director at weta workshop who portrayed sindri, one of the seven dwarf lords, ben britton. I had hoped the hobbit extended edition would live up to the high standards set by the lord of the rings extended editions which had four commentary tracks apiece.
The hobbit 5 facts from the peter jackson commentary. Tolkien 18921973 was a distinguished academic, though he is best known for writing the hobbit, the lord of the rings and the silmarillion, plus other stories and essays. Peter jackson has once again stepped up as satans little helper to direct the twopart film and is once again using witchcraft and wizardry to peddle the film, even though the books had strong christian undertones good vs evil. What would bilbo baggins have changed if he was given the chance to relive the quest for erebor. Peter jackson quotes from if you take the hobbit and the lord of the rings as books, one is written for children, and one is an adults book. Anyone else superdisappointed the hobbit extended blu has. The isnt in any of the lord of the rings films, the first hobbit film, or the book at any point.
Peter jackson says he winged it on the hobbit youtube. Why i dislike peter jacksons lord of the rings and hobbit. He is best known as the director, writer, and producer of the lord of the rings trilogy 200103 and the hobbit trilogy 201214. Resident tolkienite anna klassen compares the film to the original novel, revealing 19 differences between the tolkien classic. I didnt know that jackson had tried to read the books earlier but was bored by them and only got engaged after they got the contract to make the movie. Apr 26, 20 an archive of our own, a project of the organization for transformative works. The book had a beautiful story that didnt require a lot of padding to provide a terrific adventure for readers. But jackson had to do his own thing and grab for some extra cash by making what should have been at most two films into three. The truth is though, that peter jackson had two mutually exclusive goals to set for these movies. The filmmaker along with hobbit movie trilogy cowritersproducers fran walsh and philippa boyens have teased some of the scenes that will be added on, for those who are curious. All 14 peter jackson movies ranked from worst to best. This divorce has been systematically driven by the logic of hollywood.
Peter jacksons violent betrayal of tolkien the atlantic. It does appear, from credits listed at imdb for the hobbit. Dec 06, 2012 with the imminent release of the first of peter jacksons threepart adaptation of the hobbit, i revisited j. Goodreads members who liked the hobbit, or there and b. Smaug was cooler and more interesting than the balrog or sauron. And it seems that the hobbit will be the same kind of film.
Tolkiens the hobbit acknowledge that none of them come close to matching the highs of the lord of the rings. Peter jackson has revealed he began filming his blockbuster hobbit trilogy without proper preparation, in many cases shooting scenes without storyboards and completed scripts in a process he. In the two towers, he is one of the soldiers of rohan. Dec 16, 2012 francine stock talks to sir peter jackson about his new film the hobbit, the prequel to the hugely acclaimed lord of the rings trilogy. The hobbit peter jackson reason for changes from the hobbit. Find books like the hobbit, or there and back again from the worlds largest community of readers. An unexpected journey will also be made available, on dvd and bluray. Just in case a fourhour version of an eighthour trilogy was still too long for you, professional video editor david killstein has now gone and made an even more drastic cut of peter jackson s.
Peter jackson and crew did a stunning job of bringing the hobbit to life. Peter s basilica is sanitized ahead of reopening to public news briefs peter jacksons hobbit. Oct 22, 2014 peter jacksons trilogy of hobbit films, currently heading towards its climax with the release of the battle of the five armies in december, has been named as the most expensive film production. And the actors playing the key characters bilbo baggins, thorin. In peter jackson s film trilogies of the lord of the rings and the hobbit, most of the crew, their families, fans of tolkiens work and the director himself made cameos in all the movies. However, in a behindthescenes video from the hobbit set, jackson and the hobbit crew shed light on how chaotic the experience of making the hobbit was. In the fellowship of the ring, he is shown as a carrot eating resident of bree. The fact that the hobbit, not a particularly lengthy book, was expanded into two films already seemed like a bow to jackson s determination to get all of the source material up on the screen.
What more can i say a fully loaded version with all the bells and. Peter jackson on casting martin freeman for the hobbit. Director sir peter jackson talks with tolkienfan cirdan about his early doubts regarding the hobbitadaption, changes to the book by j. The hobbit is my favorite book of all time and for the purposes of film making i was happy with how this was represented. Played by losts evangeline lilly, tauriel is a character exclusive to the film adaptation of the hobbit. Review of peter jacksons first hobbit movie the volokh. Starting with an article on the guardian newspapers website, one particular part of peter jackson s comments in the appendices part 11. This commentary track is exclusive to the extended edition of the film, and. This isnt to say hes not a fan of jackons hobbit series which culminated with trilogycloser battle of the five armies in 2014. The hobbit tells a fantastic story of adventure, danger, friendship, and courage, and serves as a prequel to the even more immersive and epic book series, the lord of the rings. His books have been translated into over 50 languages and have sold many millions of copies worldwide. Peter jackson talks stars, screenplays and shooting schedules with.
Christians vs atheists but jackson being the selfproclaimed atheist he is obviously doesnt want to present. Certain corners of the internet have been outraged about the hobbit. Tolkiens 1937 novel, which i had not opened since i was a teenager. His epic film adaptation of the lord of the rings was a massive hit with critics and fans despite being intensely long and lacking certain details. Peter jackson adapted the lord of the rings and the hobbit, so why couldnt he adapt the silmarillion. Director peter jackson in his film adaptation of the hobbit abandons the intimate scale of the original wonder tale and mistakenly blows it up into mythic proportions by jackson braider. An unexpected journey, peter jacksons adaptation of j. Director sir peter jackson talks with tolkienfan cirdan about his early doubts regarding the hobbit adaption, changes to the book by j. Dec 06, 2012 theres more middleearth now that the hobbit s bigscreen saga is a trilogy. While i do agree that splitting such a small book into three films with some added fan fiction was a bit long winded. I will always recommend reading the book first because sometimes there are things added like in the lord of the rings movies that you just dont understand until youve read about the extra information in the book. Cutting the hobbit down to one commentary track effectively cuts out about 9 hours of special features that shouldve been included. Peter jackson discusses the hobbit trilogy production challenges.
He has confirmed martin freeman as bilbo baggins, taking over the role originated by ian holm in. Sir peter robert jackson onz knzm born 31 october 1961 is a new zealand film director, screenwriter, and film producer. In the published book, the hobbit, the goblins are led by azogs son bolg of the north. Even the most ardent defenders of peter jacksons threefilm adaptation of j. Dec 29, 2011 an unexpected journey will be followed one year later by the concluding chapter, the hobbit. Peter jackson has done a great job of capturing the atmosphere and themes of j. Peter jackson ends the hobbit trilogy on a high note the. We cant wait to get back to serving you all of the latest. Books similar to the hobbit, or there and back again. There and back again that bolg will appear in one or both of the next two movies in peters hobbit trilogy. It starred anthony jackson as narrator, paul daneman as bilbo and heron carvic as gandalf.
Most notably, the authors son christopher claims the movie eviscerated the book. Jan 06, 2014 im going to interpret your question as, why is peter jackson taking so many unfortunate liberties with the film version of the hobbit. At first glance, peter jackson s trilogy of epic films based on the hobbit, a slender childrens book, might appear to leave its source behind in order to make more capital out of the. The hobbit was conceived as a childrens book, but peter jackson wanted to take his adaptation in a. He was part of the team throwing stones and spears. Peter jackson if you take the hobbit and the lord of. Peter jacksons hobbit trilogy becomes most expensive film production ever. The hobbit movies were awful, and now we know why the verge. The battle of the five armies marks both an end and a beginning for peter jackson. Nov 19, 2015 peter jackson has revealed he began filming his blockbuster hobbit trilogy without proper preparation, in many cases shooting scenes without storyboards and completed scripts in a process he.
But the moment you look at as an interpretation and a. I watched peter jackson s first hobbit movie tonight. Dec 30, 2012 i read the hobbit when i was younger 12 or. Dec 28, 2011 before we see the hobbit in 2012, jackson s big boxing day release this year is the adventures of tintin, which he produced with director steven spielberg. Nov 19, 2015 peter jacksons the lord of the rings trilogy is a masterclass in filmmaking. Lord of the rings director peter jackson on his greatest moments, and how simon pegg ripped him off. The complete list of film changes for the hobbit and the lord of.
169 1207 995 8 1296 1079 140 1328 260 162 378 859 159 1158 1543 1219 122 96 724 1275 192 398 773 510 956 1394 1376 764 1034 569 941 126 131 1165